3 Best Beanies for Men in 2024 [Tried & Tested]

Best Beanies for Men

If you don’t currently have a beanie in your wardrobe, then maybe it’s time to invest in one.

Contrary to what many people may think, the beanie is so much more than a winter ear warmer.

It can be a Spring fashion accessory or a Fall wardrobe essential, you can even wear one on the cooler Summer days if you’re brave enough!

Let’s dive into our top picks for the best beanies for men. Here they are…

👑 Our Pick for Best Overall

⭐ Our Other Picks for Best Beanies for Men

• Best of the Best: Carhartt Knit Cuffed Beanie
• Runner Up: OZERO Winter Beanie
• Best Wool Alternative: Cotton Cuffed Beanie

Best Beanies for Men Reviews

Carhartt Knit Cuffed Beanie (👑 Best of the Best)

If you’re looking for the best in beanies, then hands-down your best bet is the classic Carhartt knit cuffed beanie.

Our top pick for the best men’s beanie has accrued a five-star rating on Amazon, which is impressive in itself, but what makes it even more so is the fact that more than 110,000 past customers have offered their two cents. As you might imagine, the product is listed as a number one Best Seller on Amazon, which speaks volumes for its popularity. If ever there was a clothing item from one brand that dominated the market, it’d be the Carhartt beanie. The name ‘Carhartt’ has almost become synonymous with the beanie, that’s the extent to which the brand has built a reputation.

That’s all well and good, you might be sitting there thinking to yourself, but what makes this beanie so special?

We’re glad you asked!

The first thing you’ll likely notice when you visit the Carhartt beanie is that it’s available in as many as 24 different colors. That’s when you know a product is good, not because it offers a lot of variety, but because it has obviously been so successful with customers that the brand has expanded the range drastically to encompass all the colors of the rainbow. There’s something for every style and preference, from a deep red wine color to cobalt blue, and sandstone to chilli. Since the beanie is becoming more and more a fashion accessory, it’s a huge plus to have so much choice when it comes to color. After all, if you’re limited to four or five colors and none of them match well with your current wardrobe then you won’t be able to pull off the look you want. Plus, while neutral colors are always nice, the Carhartt beanie lets you really express yourself with bright and vibrant options such as orange and cobalt blue.

But that’s not all. It’s perhaps the construction and design of the Carhartt beanie that has made it an astronomically popular clothing item. The rib-knit acrylic fabric construction means that the beanie should feel warm and stretchable, so it should be a great ear warmer for the colder days. The beanie also comes with Carhartt’s promise of ‘classic Carhartt durability’, which if you’re familiar with the brand, you’ll know means that the beanie is tough enough to last many years. The brand has been around the block for more than 130 years, and has always been dedicated to fabricating the highest quality clothing that withstands the test of time.

The beanie is also machine washable, which means that you’ll be able to get any bad smells or sweat out of it in the washing machine. Then of course there’s the iconic Carhartt logo that takes pride of place front and center on the beanie’s front band. The logo has become synonymous with high-quality craftsmanship over the years, so it will feel like wearing a badge of honor.

OZERO Winter Beanie (🥈 Runner Up)

The Ozero winter beanie is of course a beanie that’s meant for keeping your ears and head warm during the colder months.

Another top-rated beanie on Amazon, the Ozero winter beanie is listed as an ‘Amazon’s Choice’ product which says a lot about its quality and popularity among customers. This warm beanie is available in five different colors, which makes it easy to find the perfect style for your wardrobe. You can either opt for the bold maize yellow beanie which will make you stand out as you glide down the slopes, the striking traffic purple which is ideal for brisk walks around the city, or the one of the three neutral colors including navy blue, black, and gray which are fit for just about any occasion.

What makes this such a good beanie for winter?

It’s all in the material. This beanie is made from high-quality thermal knit wool shell and a warm polar fleece lining for superior comfort. Whenever you think of warm winter clothes, wool is probably the first material that comes to mind. It’s incredibly cosy, and it’s probably the material in 90% of your warmest winter sweaters and hats. Plus, in the case of this beanie from Ozero, the wool is a soft and breathable material which means if you enjoy working out and going on runs in the cold weather it’ll still be comfortable to wear. As such, this is a fantastic beanie for the active lifestyle, for when the weather outside is cold but there’s a fire burning within you.

Style-wise, the beanie has a classic knitted style which will go down a treat with your grandma but also with your peers. It’s cozy yet fashionable, like a warm cardigan or sweater. It’s a beanie that wouldn’t look out of place on a hike or gathered around a campfire. The size of the beanie is intended to adapt to the shape and size of every individual’s head, yet still has a snug fit. If you’re looking to give a great gift at Christmas, this beanie can be an excellent choice, and unlike ugly socks the lucky recipient will get a lot of use out of it.

Features:

•  Made from thermal knit wool shell and polar fleece lining
•  Elastic knit fabric closure 
•  100% stretchy polyester 
•  One size 
•  Available in 5 colors

Cotton Cuffed Beanie (🐑 Best Wool Alternative)

If you’re tired of feeling like you have to lift up your wool beanie to scratch an itch that doesn’t seem to go away, then you might like to try out this cotton alternative.

Cotton is a material that many people would typically associate with the beanie, but hear us out, since this is an excellent alternative option to wool. The number one issue most people have with wool, is that it can irritate the skin and make you feel itchy. All the time. This is the last thing you want when you’re just trying to get cozy and feel comfortable in your warm winter clothes. Whether it’s a thick wool sweater that someone in your family knitted or a wool beanie that you thought would be great for winter, the itchiness can be a real problem. One of the best solutions if this is a dealbreaker for you is to invest in a beanie made from a different material, like cotton.

This cuffed beanie is made from 100% cotton, which means it’s going to be a much better choice if you’re quick to overheat. If breathability is something you prioritize with clothing because you live an active lifestyle, then you’ll probably want to give this cotton beanie a go. After all, there’s a good reason why we usually wear cotton t-shirts and not wool t-shirts. This beanie should fit to your head with just the right amount of snugness, but also enough stretch to adjust if necessary.

Another great aspect of this cotton beanie is that it comes in eight different colors, which makes experimentation a possibility. Sure, you could go for the plain charcoal beanie if you want something neutral that works well with most colors, or you could be bold and go for the bright red or blue beanie for a pop of color to elevate your style. The beanie isn’t just for keeping your ears warm, but it should be seen as an extension of your style, and as such you should try and find one that will work well with your current wardrobe.

Features:

•  100% cotton 
•  Fitted closure
•  Available in 8 colors

Ultimate Guide

Choosing the right men’s beanie can be difficult.

Looking at a photo of the beanie on an online retailer will give you an idea of what it looks like, but not much else.

It’s hard to tell whether or not the beanie will stretch over your head and fit snugly, and difficult to tell how comfortable it will be to wear and how thick the material is.

As such, you’ll need to go in knowing what the different materials will feel like on your head as well as the importance of other factors such as the thickness and style of the beanie.

Related: How to Wear a Beanie for Men

Material

The most important factor to consider before you invest in a new beanie is the material that it’s made from.

You have natural materials, and then you have artificial materials.

We’re going to take a look at the most popular natural and artificial materials to give you an idea of what they might feel like to wear.

Natural

A lot of people will prefer natural materials just because they are sourced naturally and will likely be of higher quality in most cases.

• Wool

Wool has a reputation as being the go-to Winter clothing material, which makes sense given that it’s incredibly warming.

This organic fabric also offers you a robust, water-resistant material that will be well-insulated and will dry quickly.

Wool beanies will feel warm and cozy like your favorite sweater, but they might also make your head itch.

• Cotton

Cotton is a slightly uncommon option for beanies, as it’s more of a hot weather material, but it does offer several big benefits.

For a start, cotton is lightweight, hypoallergenic, and breathable.

That means you’re less likely to overheat when you wear a cotton beanie out and about, and it shouldn’t feel burdensome on your head.

Artificial

Artificial materials are also a highly common option for beanies, since they lend a lot of useful qualities such as elasticity and can often be cheaper.

• Acrylic

Acrylic is by far the best artificial material for a beaner, which is why the top brand Carhartt uses 100% acrylic to fabricate their superior quality beanies.

This is a good material because it imitates a lot of wool’s qualities without coming from the animal. It’s warm, water-resistant, and durable which are all hugely important in a beanie.

• Polyester

Polyester is another artificial material often used in clothing and beanies.

Polyester offers durability and longevity, and it’s a much cheaper option than most other materials.

Style

Style is another huge factor when it comes to buying the perfect beanie.

These days, it’s just as common to wear a beanie as a fashion accessory than it is to wear one to keep warm in cold weather.

To assess the style and see if it’s a good fit for your needs, we recommend that you consider the following factors:

Color

The impact of color on style cannot be overstated.

While in most cases a lot of us will choose the neutral color like black or gray so as not to interfere with the rest of our outfit, adding a touch of color in the form of an accessory like a beanie can be a powerful form of personality expression.

Many beanies offer one or two different colors, but if you really want to use it as a bold fashion statement, then you’ll have to look at an option like the Carhartt beanie which has an extensive range of 24+ colors to choose from.

Thickness

The thickness of the beanie is another important factor when it comes to style, though it also makes a difference for the warmth and level of comfort too.

If you go for a thin beanie that’s made from a lightweight material such as cotton you’ll have a much easier time rolling it up and still feeling comfortable though by exposing your ears you will feel the cold more readily.

With a thick wool beanie on the other hand, rolling it up might make the top of your extra warm and offers a different style to the uncuffed beanie, albeit at the risk of overheating.

Type

Believe it or not, there’s more than one type of beanie out there.

Many more, in fact, so it’s in your interest to find out exactly which types of beanies will work best for you.

For example, there’s the bobble hat beanie which is a bolder Winter style and there’s the fisherman beanie which gives off more of a workman-like look.

Then there’s the good old classic cuffed beanie look which is favored by most beanie-wearers, since it is both simple and stylish at the same time.

Frequently Asked Questions About Men’s Beanies

What are the best brands for beanies?

Without a doubt Carhartt is the name that comes across most people’s minds when they think of beanies.

The brand has developed a strong reputation due to their high-quality clothing and iconic beanies, which can withstand the rigor of everyday life and keep your head nice and warm.

If you’re looking to invest in a reliable beanie that’ll serve you for years to come, you shouldn’t look any further than Carhartt.

How do I find the best Beanie?

To find the best beanie for you, there’s going to be several factors that you’ll need to keep in mind.

For a start, you’ll want to consider what you want the beanie for, is it just a fashion accessory for mild spring weather or an investment in the warmth of your ears for those bitterly cold Winter mornings?

You also need to consider what your personal preferences are and how they line up with the various styles of beanies out there.

Should a beanie cover your ears?

When it comes to the beanie, there’s a variety of ways you can wear it depending on the type of look you’re going for.

When it’s cold out, you’ll obviously want that extra ear protection and warmth so naturally you’ll have the beanie cover your ears.

But when you want to experiment with different looks, you can try cuffing one side over your ear, both, or slipping the beanie back to create a high-top style.

A Final Word From The Trending Man

Beanies are very versatile, and can complete a man’s look regardless of the season.

Provided you can get your hands on the right beanie for you, it can prove to be an invaluable investment for your wardrobe for years to come.